Should You Use A Livescribe “Smartpen” At Client Meetings?

Wednesday, August 04, 2010 14:41
edit
Should You Use A Livescribe “Smartpen” At Client Meetings?

Financial advisor Karl Hicks is using a Livescribe “smartpen” to take notes at his client meetings. Livescribe records your conversations and digitizes your handwritten notes, automatically synching your notes with the audio. Does it really work?

This Website Is For Financial Professionals Only


LiveScribe smartpens cost from $129 to $199 at Best Buy and they write like regular pens. But these pens are equipped with a digital recorder.

Simply click the “record” button on the special Livescribe paper and the pen records audio of conversations or lectures while you take notes. So everything your clients tell you during a quarterly review meeting is captured in audio as well as in your sketchy notes. After the meeting, you can play back exactly what the client said.

Say during a meeting with a client, you cover four important issues:  Alimony payments, using a Schwab money market fund to cover expenses for her child’s camp, speaking with her attorney about a testamentary trust, and using her Citicorp account to fund the tax liability on a Roth IRA conversion. During the meeting, you want to be in the moment, able to concentrate on what she is saying and be able to ask questions about it. You don’t want to be distracted with taking notes.

With Livescribe, as each of these issues come up during the meeting, you simply write down the keywords: Alimony, Schwab account, trust, and Roth. Later, just tap on your keyword notes to hear exactly what the client said about each topic.

Livescribe is not creating a written transcript of the conversation. That would require really sophisticated voice transcription software. But it is giving you an audio record of exactly what was said in conversations.

Notes and audio can also be uploaded to a computer where they can be replayed, saved, searched, and sent.
Livescribe has two models of smartpens –
Echo (8GB) and Pulse (4GB), which record more than 400 and 800 hours of audio respectively. The special pads and notebooks come in a variety of sizes, and you can add a charging cradle and carrying cases.

Livescribe paper has lots of micro
dots. Livescribe has a camera, located at the tip of the smartpen, that takes 72 photos of the dots, spaced 0.3mm apart, creating images of 1.8 x 1.8mm grids of 36 dots. That recreates your handwriting. Each picture of the dots is decoded by software in the smartpen to tell the smartpen exactly its position on any given page.

So you can understand how an advisor uses Livescribe, I asked
Karl Hicks of Leonard Financial Group in Riverside, California, a series of questions. Here’s what he says:  

Is Livescribe good?
Good is a relative term. The pen writes very well and the document capture is good. But if your handwriting is bad, the accuracy of the recorded document would be bad, too.

How long have you had it?
I got it last year.

How many times a week do you use it?
I use it several times a week. I write with it most of the time without recording, but I record our weekly office meetings and all of my client meetings, and I have used it at a few other meetings, committees, and workshops.

What is the best use for it?
Reviewing the conversation around a particular line of notes.

How hard is it to get into the habit?
As hard as it is for someone to learn to start the recorder and take notes. The biggest problem might be to remember to charge it.

How long did it take you to figure it out?
Pretty darn simple. It’s not at all complicated. The hardest thing is getting the software loaded on your computer, if you want to be able to upload documents.

What do you like and dislike about it?
As a pen, it’s as good as any pen I’ve ever used. I like being able to review the audio recording form a meeting "linked" to a line of notes. The drawbacks are the integration of the computer “documents” with other documents in your system. LiveScribe has its own software and, even though the documents can be saved as PDF files, I don’t think the audio travels with the file. And for me the linked audio is the main reason I bought the Pulse Pen.

Is it just another gadget that you’ll eventually tire of or really sticky?
I won’t tire of it. I use it in all my client meetings. I could see a huge value for students taking notes as well. Even if I stopped using the recording function (which I don't foresee), I would still use it as a pen--although it would be an expensive pen. 

Who is the type of person that would like it the most? Who would not like it?
Note-takers who use their notes to define actions and next steps, or someone who often looks back at his notes to figure out exactly what was said to prompt a particular note. Because the pen is a little bulky, it might not be ideal for someone who travels from site-to-site and does not want to hassle with the pen or deal with having to use the special paper. There are several different sizes to choose, however.

Why not just get a tablet?
I had a tablet. It’s a different tool with a different purpose. Also, the pen and accessories are less than $250. A good tablet with the proper software is minimum $1,000. The battery on the pen lasts much longer as well.



 

Comments (7)

...
billwinterberg
One of the tablet PC options to which you referred is Microsoft OneNote.

Similar use to that of Livescribe can be done with OneNote, but the cost for a tablet PC and software, as you said, is higher than the pen.
billwinterberg , August 05, 2010
...
cfp4lf
Why not just use a regular digital recorder and note the topic and time in your notes? It's cheaper and you don't need special paper.
cfp4lf , August 10, 2010
...
billwinterberg
You make a good point. The pen is an elegant solution as it is unobtrusive and records automatically in the background. Once it starts recording, it's set and forget.

That's a better alternative than a clunky tablet PC running OneNote; clients may feel that they do not have the full attention of an advisor operating a tablet PC.

But as you said, a simple digital recorder is an inexpensive solution, provided that one is in the habit of noting time stamps in written notes after peeking at the recorder from time to time.
billwinterberg , August 10, 2010
...
agluck
I think CFP4F is missing the point. (No pun intended.)

When you takes notes with the Livescribes, it's real easy later to find the exact section of the conversation where you referenced the note.

I don't think you want to have to remember to time stamps every note you take. That's a hassle you avoid with the Livescribe.

Plus, if you time stamp five or 10 important snippets of the recording, how will you know which snippet is which? You'll know you time stamped something but later won't easily be able to pinpoint the location on your recording of the idea that you're looking for.

Also, as long as you live in a single party consent state, recording a conversation with a client without telling him he's being recorded is legal. Just 1 states are NOT single party consent states.

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T...rding_laws for for information.

Since recorders make people uneasy, you may want to use your Livescribe without mentioning to people you're recording them--unless you feel it's just wrong to hide the fact that you're recording the meeting or you fear some sort of Advisorgate scnadal..
agluck , August 11, 2010
...
Jayne Ferrante
Can you transfer the conversation to your hard drive for storage? Also I'd love to record the notes that end up in Junxure from my meetings and my list of to-dos. If not a Livescribe, has anyone used Dragon speaking naturally to dictate straight into a word doc or whatever program they use and then transfer to Junxure (CRM)?

Thanks

jaynef559 , August 13, 2010
...
billwinterberg
Hopefully a Livescribe user can chime in on how audio files are managed. Perhaps their website FAQ has some details.

I use Dragon Dictation often, a free app for iPhone/iPad to transcribe short email messages and copy the text into contact software. I also use it to transcribe blog posts. The transcription accuracy is fairly good, especially considering that the app is free.
billwinterberg , August 13, 2010
...
agluck
Yes, you can transfer audio files from your Livescribe pen to your computer using a USB connection that comes with the Livescribe.

You can also post "Pencasts" to the Web. You can see some Pencasts at http://www.livescribe.com/cgi-...erviewPage
agluck , August 13, 2010

Write comment

You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy